From Blaseball Wiki

This page contains FORBIDDEN KNOWLEDGE: information about the game of Blaseball that has not been revealed by Blaseball itself. This knowledge may diminish the mysteriousness of the game. Proceed at your own discretion.

Fingers are a type of digit primarily used as an organ of sensation and manipulation typically found on the hands of Earth primates. In Blaseball, it is a player attribute.

Fingers in Blaseball

Fingers are believed to be a mutagenic property that affects playing capability. Players enter the league with 10 total fingers and gain (but never lose) them in whole number amounts. This typically occurs via blessings such as the Literal Arm Cannon (Axel Trololol) or Max Out Pitcher (PolkaDot Patterson), or via peanut reactions during a game.